Apple Butter and Thyme Baked Brie (Glossy, Not Runny)

Apple butter and thyme baked brie solves the most common baked brie complaint: a fruit topping that thins out and slides off the wheel. Apple butter is already cooked down, so it stays on top as a glossy glaze while the cheese softens underneath. The recipe serves 6 and takes 21 minutes from first step to table, with 6 minutes of prep and a bake of up to 15. It needs five ingredients, one small dish and a sharp knife for scoring. The result is warm, mellow cheese under a sweet, spiced layer, finished with toasted walnuts, a little thyme and flaky salt. It suits a fall board, a casual get-together or a quiet night in.

Why this works

• Apple butter carries almost no free water, so the top stays a glaze instead of thinning into a puddle.
• Scoring the rind in a crosshatch lets the heat in and gives the topping something to sit on.
• A snug dish holds the wheel upright while the center softens.
• Walnuts and thyme go on after the bake, so the nuts stay crisp and the herb stays green.

The bake is short, 12 to 15 minutes at 350 F (175 C). That is long enough to soften the center and not so long that the cheese runs out of its rind.

What to know about the ingredients

The brie. Buy a double cream brie in an 8 oz wheel, about 5 in across. The recipe is written for that size, and a snug dish matters more than the brand. Choose a wheel that feels slightly soft and has an even white rind.

The apple butter. Use a smooth, thick apple butter. If yours looks loose or watery, it will not hold as a glaze. You only need a thin layer, not a mound, so a small jar covers it with plenty to spare for crackers.

The walnuts. Walnut pieces toast quickly and smell nutty when ready. Pecans make a fair swap if that is what you have, and the toasting cue stays the same.

Thyme and salt. Fresh thyme leaves give a clean, woodsy contrast to the sweetness. Dried thyme works in a pinch, but use less and add it before the bake. Flaky sea salt matters here because it adds a bright crunch at the end.

Apple Butter and Thyme Baked Brie

Print recipe Save to Pinterest

Apple butter is already cooked down, so it never turns watery on top of the wheel.

Prep6 min

Cook15 min

Total21 min

Serves6

Ingredients

• Brie wheel, double cream — 8 oz wheel (225 g)
• Apple butter — ⅓ cup (80 g)
• Walnut pieces — ⅓ cup (35 g)
• Fresh thyme leaves — 1 teaspoon (2 g)
• Flaky sea salt — ¼ teaspoon (1 g)

Instructions

1. Heat the oven to 350 F (175 C) and toast the walnut pieces on a small tray until they smell nutty, 5 to 6 minutes.
2. Score the top rind in a crosshatch of 1 in (2.5 cm) squares, about 3 mm deep, until the paste shows in the cuts.
3. Spread the apple butter over the scored top until the rind is covered to the edge, with a thin layer, not a mound.
4. Bake in a snug dish 12 to 15 minutes, until the apple butter looks glossy and the center gives under one finger.
5. Scatter the toasted walnuts and thyme over the top until the surface is evenly covered.
6. Finish with the flaky salt and serve while the center still moves when the dish is nudged, and rewarm it 3 minutes until it moves again if it sets.

Notes

• Bake at 350 F (175 C) for 12 to 15 minutes. Wheel size: 225 g / 8 oz wheel, 5 in across.

Nutrition per serving

186Calories

9 gProtein

6 gCarbs

14 gFat

Estimated per serving from standard nutrition reference values; will vary with brands and substitutions.

Tips for getting it right

1. Toast the walnuts first. Use the same oven while it heats. Pull them when they smell nutty, then set them aside so they do not keep cooking on the hot tray.
2. Score to the paste. Cut the crosshatch until you can see the paste in the cuts, about 3 mm deep. Any shallower and the cheese will not open up.
3. Spread thin to the edge. Cover the rind all the way to the edge with a thin layer. A mound slides off and scorches.
4. Judge by feel, not the clock. The apple butter should look glossy, and the center should give under one finger. If it does not, give it a few more minutes.
5. Add the walnuts and thyme last. Scatter them until the surface is evenly covered, then finish with the salt.
6. Serve while it moves. The center should still shift when you nudge the dish. If it sets, rewarm it for 3 minutes until it moves again.

How to store, freeze and make ahead

Toast the walnuts up to 5 days ahead and keep them in a closed container at room temperature. Everything else takes 3 minutes to assemble, so there is little to prep in advance. Bake the wheel when guests arrive and plan to finish it in one sitting, since the texture is best while the center is still loose. If a little is left, cover it and refrigerate it, then rewarm it until it softens. This recipe does not give a freezing method, so skip the freezer.

What to serve with it

Oat crackers and slices of sharp cheddar are the first pairings. The nutty crunch of the oats and the sharp bite of the cheddar balance the sweetness. Crisp apple slices, sliced pears, grapes and a toasted baguette also work, and a handful of extra nuts fills out the board. For a drink, something dry and crisp suits the apple, whether that is sparkling water, cider or a light white wine.

Variations

• Pecan instead of walnut. Toast pecans the same way and finish as written.
• Sharper sweet. Swap the thyme for a little fresh rosemary, minced fine.
• Warm spice. Add a pinch of cinnamon to the apple butter before spreading.
• Savory edge. Lay a few thin slices of prosciutto on the board beside the wheel, not on top.

For more ways to build your next appetizer, see our guide to Baked Brie and Cheese Boards, or try the Maple Pecan Baked Brie and the Spiced Pear Baked Brie next.